The short answer
Test each shortlisted module in the same representative letter using its correct supply voltage and the real face material. Keep the first comparison conditions consistent, then optimise each permitted layout independently. Record visible uniformity, module count, operating voltage, connected load and installation time. Select the arrangement that meets the agreed appearance and installation requirements at an acceptable total project cost.
1. Define a pass before comparing suppliers
Start with the finished sign rather than the headline lumen figure. Write down the required lighting effect, viewing distance, face colour, letter depth and operating environment. Decide who will approve the illuminated sample and under what conditions. A restaurant sign viewed from across a road and a small reception logo viewed at arm’s length need different assessments.
Choose a difficult but representative letter. A broad straight stroke alone may hide problems at tight corners, narrow joins and counters. If the alphabet contains significantly different shapes, test more than one. Keep the same acrylic grade, thickness, vinyl or print treatment and internal finish that will be used in production. A different face material makes the comparison less useful.
2. Shortlist complete modules, not chip names
Ask for the current datasheet and installation instructions for the exact variant. Confirm voltage, power per module, dimensions, colour temperature, optical distribution, maximum modules per feed and mounting requirements. Check the stated warranty and the route for obtaining matching replacements. Do not assume two products with the same LED chip or nominal beam angle behave identically.
For Glowfy GL K2 PRO or GL K8 PRO, use the specification of the selected variant and request clarification where a figure is missing. This test method does not assign a universal winner to either model. A larger output or body can be useful in one letter and awkward in another. The sample needs to prove suitability for the actual fabrication.
- Keep each sample’s model, colour variant and batch information with its datasheet.
- Check that modules physically fit without covering fixings or stressing their wires.
- Confirm environmental suitability for the module, connections and complete installation.
- Review documentation and warranty terms before committing to the production order.
3. Run a controlled comparison, then a layout comparison
The first comparison holds the shell, face, viewing position and ambient lighting constant. Where the product instructions allow it, use the same module positions to see differences in light distribution. Supply each sample at its own specified voltage and verify that voltage at the module feed under load. Never connect a 12V module to 24V just to use the same bench supply.
Next, optimise each product’s arrangement within its installation limits. A fair purchasing decision compares the best acceptable layout for each product, not only equal quantities. One option may require extra modules to illuminate a wide stroke; another may need closer attention around a tight corner. Change one layout variable at a time and photograph each revision before moving on.
Manufacturer density charts are starting points tied to stated face materials and depths. They are not interchangeable between brands. SloanLED’s channel-letter density guidance, for example, identifies the face material behind its figures and recommends testing outside the listed conditions. Use the equivalent guidance for the product being evaluated.
4. Judge the face with your eyes and a consistent record
Look for bright dots, dark bands, shadows at returns and a change of colour between sections. Inspect the face straight on and from the intended viewing angles. Repeat the check under the lighting conditions in which the customer will judge the sign. A sample that looks impressive in a dark workshop can still be unsuitable for the required presentation.
Keep camera position, exposure and white balance fixed when recording comparisons. Automatic exposure can make two visibly different samples appear equally bright; an overexposed face can hide hotspots. Photographs support the decision, but do not replace an in-person assessment. A light meter used at recorded positions can help repeat a test; it does not establish total module lumens or laboratory photometric performance.
| Record | What to keep constant or note | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Shell and face | Actual depth, acrylic, decoration and finish | Controls the light path |
| Layout | Module count, positions and distance to returns | Makes the result reproducible |
| Electrical conditions | Correct voltage, feed points and load | Separates optics from supply problems |
| Assessment | Viewing distance, room light and camera settings | Prevents misleading comparisons |
| Acceptance | Approved photo and written observations | Creates a production reference |
5. Calculate the whole layout: an illustrative example
Imagine two fictional layouts that both pass the same face test. Layout A uses 24 modules at 1.2W each: 24 Ă— 1.2 = 28.8W. Layout B uses 30 modules at 0.8W each: 30 Ă— 0.8 = 24W. At 12V their nominal load currents are 2.4A and 2A respectively. These are teaching figures, not specifications for Glowfy or competing brands, and actual input should be checked in the finished system.
The second layout uses more pieces but less nominal power. That alone does not make it cheaper. Include module price, the number of complete packs purchased, cable and distribution, supply capacity, assembly time and spare-stock requirements. Calculate power-supply capacity from the whole sign and its manufacturer’s operating limits. A lower module count can save labour while a lower load may reduce supply requirements; the project decides which matters most.
For an energy comparison, state the operating hours. A 4.8W difference over 3,000 hours is 14.4kWh of LED-side energy per year. A mains energy comparison also includes supply losses. Multiply measured mains consumption by the customer’s actual tariff rather than promising a fixed annual saving.
6. Release a documented layout to production
Operate the sample long enough to assess it under stable working conditions using the product instructions. A short workshop trial can reveal obvious layout and connection problems, but cannot validate a five-year life claim or prove an ingress rating. Do not invent a life expectancy from a successful bench test.
Freeze the accepted module positions, feed arrangement and material specification. Keep a photograph before the face is fitted and a photograph of the approved illuminated result. If the face, module model or depth changes later, review the layout again rather than treating the old approval as transferable. Retain the information needed to reproduce the installation during maintenance.
- Record the accepted model, variant, quantity and supplier reference.
- Record supply voltage, connected load, feed limits and cable arrangement.
- Keep the actual face and finish specification with the job sheet.
- Agree the appearance with the customer and retain the approval.
- Confirm replacement availability and label the installation for future service.
Frequently asked questions
Should I compare the same number of LED modules?
Use equal positions where permitted for an initial optical comparison, then optimise each layout separately. Compare the total cost and loading of layouts that both meet the same acceptance criteria.
Does a wider beam always need fewer modules?
No. The result also depends on lens distribution, output, depth, face transmission and letter shape. Prove the spacing with the real face.
Can a phone photograph prove one module is brighter?
Not by itself. Automatic exposure and white balance can conceal differences. Lock the settings and confirm the result in person; use suitable measurements for any numerical performance claim.
Can Glowfy help shortlist modules?
Send the letter dimensions, depth, face material, intended lighting effect and installation environment through the project enquiry form. Confirm the final layout using representative samples.
Technical references
Use the current datasheet for the exact product you install. These manufacturer and standards resources explain the general principles.
Put the sample test into practice
Tell us about your letter depth and face material. Request suitable Glowfy module samples before committing to the full sign.